Engaged and Felt Like Experimenting

I know I’m engaged to Sarah but we wanted to spice things up. She said she’d always been curious about anal play, so after dinner last night, I got her some lube and toys from the drawer. We started off slow with fingerplay until she was ready for a toy. It felt so tight when I first pushed it in, then as she relaxed more, I could feel how wet and eager she was for me to take her deeper. She rode it like a pro until I switched to another one that vibrated. We both lost control fast, screaming each other’s names when we finally came together.